Your Brain Isn't Built for Politics—Here's What to Do About It

Instead of fighting or fleeing, use these three scientifically proven psychological strategies to quickly calm down and carry on.

Feb 17, 2025

woman in black and white striped long sleeve shirt — Photo by Julien L on Unsplash

The Hidden Reason Politics Feels Impossible

Many people assume that some people are just naturally better at politics—more resilient, thicker-skinned, or simply more immune to the emotional toll.

But here’s the truth: No one’s brain is built for this.

I hear it all the time:

I admire what you’re doing with Smart Politics, but I could never do it myself. I’d get too upset.

This perception is understandable but misguided. Political engagement is emotionally challenging for everyone—even me. The reason isn’t hypersensitivity or a lack of talent.

The real problem? Our brains are poorly adapted to politics.

Why Our Brains Are Bad at Politics

The problem isn’t just the intensity of modern politics—it’s that our brains are fundamentally ill-equipped for political stress.

For most of human history, threats were immediate and physical, requiring an instant, instinctive response. If danger arose—a predator, a rival, or a natural disaster—our nervous system would activate the fight-or-flight response, priming us to act automatically, without thinking to maximize our chance of survival.

This system served us well. Our subconscious mind detects danger up to 10 times faster than our conscious mind. That was useful when we were facing wild animals on the savannah, but not so much now when we are doomscrolling on social media.

Our challenge is that modern political stress is nothing like the dangers our ancestors faced. Today’s threats are:

Gradual → Issues like climate collapse, nuclear proliferation, and pollution unfold over years or decades.
Constant → Political news, social media, and 24-hour cycles keep us in a perpetual state of high alert.
Complex → Most of our problems lack simple, intuitive solutions.
Intangible→ Threats like economic inequality and civil liberties violations are abstract and hard to grasp

Your Brain Is Like a Smoke Alarm That’s Bad at Its Job

Imagine living in a house where the smoke alarm goes off every time you burn toast—but stays silent while an electrical fire spreads behind the walls.

That’s how your nervous system responds to modern politics.

It overreacts to small, immediate threats. A viral tweet, a cable news alert, or an argument at Thanksgiving can send your stress levels through the roof—because they feel urgent and personal.
It underreacts to slow-moving catastrophes. Climate change, erosion of international relationships, and nuclear proliferation unfold too gradually to trigger a strong emotional response, even though they pose far greater risks.
It short-circuits under constant overload. When political chaos is nonstop, like during the Trump presidency, your brain can’t sustain high alert forever. Eventually, it either shuts down (numbness, disengagement) or burns out (anxiety, despair).

The result? We waste energy on the wrong alarms while ignoring the real fire.

We’re stuck with a brain that panics at distractions but ignores real danger. And that’s exactly what authoritarian leaders exploit.

Why This Moment Is Especially Hard

The Trump-Musk regime isn’t just another political crisis. It’s an existential threat to democracy itself.

This is unlike anything most of us have experienced in our lifetimes. It's more stressful than politics as usual—and that makes it even harder to regulate our emotions.

Yet, precisely because this moment is so dire, calming ourselves is more important than ever. As I explained earlier this month, authoritarians benefit when we panic.

Panic Benefits Trump

Karin Tamerius

Feb 3

The day after the inauguration, my sister received a text message that read, “January 20, 2025 is the day democracy died in America. They are in control now. There’s nothing we can do.”

Read full story

The Good News: We Can Calm Down Quickly

This mismatch between our ancient brain and the nature of modern political threats is why so many of us feel:

Emotionally drained
Trapped in cycles of anxiety and frustration
Struggling to stay engaged without burning out

However, once we understand why our emotional reactions are so dysregulated, we can work with our nervous system rather than against it.

Managing political stress effectively doesn’t mean ignoring politics or merely insulating ourselves from its worst excesses. It means using psychology to manage our emotions to stay calm and respond strategically.

In politics, unlike in nature, we must think before we react in order to survive.

The Science of Calming Down So You Can Carry On

If political engagement is overwhelming for you right now, that doesn’t mean you’re incapable of participating; it just means no one ever taught you how to manage it.

Just as our brain has a built-in alarm system, it also has a “calming system”—the parasympathetic nervous system—which helps restore balance when we aren’t in danger.

At its best, this “calm down” system:

Lowers heart rate and blood pressure
Relaxes tight muscles
Encourages deeper, slower breathing
Reactivates essential processes, like digestion, that were put on hold

Most people assume this system only kicks in on its own—but you can activate it deliberately.

Do you know someone who is struggling to stay calm and carry on? Share this article with them for free!

Three Strategies to Calm Down Quickly

When political stress arises, we need quick and easy techniques for resetting our emotions. Simple strategies such as box breathing, grounding, and labeling emotions can rapidly calm the body and redirect the mind, making way for more thoughtful and strategic political action.

Box breathing directly engages the “slow-down” system, counteracting the effects of stress hormones and fostering relaxation.
Grounding redirects your attention from distressing thoughts and emotions toward sensory input in the present moment.
Naming emotions engages the prefrontal cortex, which helps you control your impulses and think more rationally.

These tools aren’t merely quick fixes—when used consistently, they train your brain to handle stress with greater resilience over time.

1. Box Breathing

Box breathing, or square breathing, is a calming technique that helps regulate your nervous system with a simple, rhythmic pattern of respiration:

Inhale deeply in through your nose for a count of four.
Hold your breath for a count of four.
Exhale slowly out through your mouth for a count of four.
Hold your breath again for a count of four.

Continue this in-and-out cycle for several rounds until your emotional arousal level returns to baseline.

What the research says: Doing box breathing for just a few minutes reduces stress hormones, slows heart rate, and lowers blood pressure, producing a feeling of relaxation. It’s so effective it’s used by the Navy SEALs and in the treatment of panic attacks and PTSD. Regular practice of box breathing increases heart rate variability (HRV), an important marker of healthy biological resilience, while also improving focus and mood.12

2. Grounding

Political stress often draws our thoughts into fears about the future or recriminations about the past. Grounding helps you break free from this cycle of negative rumination by redirecting your attention to sensations in the present moment.

There are many popular grounding techniques, but one I particularly like is the 5-4-3-2-1 method, which involves identifying:

5 things you can see,
4 things you can touch,
3 things you can hear,
2 things you can smell, and
1 thing you can taste.

For example, I might notice the sound of my keyboard, the feel of my chair, and the scent of my coffee. This interrupts anxiety by shifting focus to the present.

What the research says: Since fear and sensation are processed in different brain areas, this technique serves as an escape hatch from the fight-or-flight response. When used in the management of anxiety and trauma, grounding decreases the sense of being overwhelmed and fosters a feeling of safety.34

3. Naming Emotions

When political stress feels overwhelming, naming your emotions can help you reset fast. This practice, known as “affect labeling,” involves identifying and verbalizing—out loud or in writing—what you’re feeling, whether your emotions are anger, fear, sadness, frustration, or some combination.

For example, right now, I am experiencing the following emotions:

I am scared that the Trump administration may be doing irreparable damage to our democracy.
I am angry that civil rights hard won over the course of decades are being rolled back
I am tired of spending most of my time fighting to preserve what we have rather than building something even better.

What the research shows: Naming emotions works because it engages the prefrontal cortex, the brain’s logical and regulatory center, while reducing activity in the amygdala, the brain’s fear center. This dual action distances you from your emotions while giving you more control or your thoughts and actions. Naming emotions is especially useful in situations where feelings run high, such as when we are so triggered that we can barely think straight.567

Calm Your Brain, Save Democracy

To defend democracy, we need to stay calm by working with our nervous system, rather than against it.

The overwhelm and exhaustion so many of us feel isn’t a sign of weakness—it’s a sign that our brain wasn’t designed for chronic political stress.

The good news? Just as our brains have built-in alarm systems, they also have mechanisms for calming down. And we can learn to activate them on demand.

Start now. Pick one technique—box breathing, grounding, or naming emotions—and practice it for the next 24 hours.

The stronger our emotional resilience, the harder we are to manipulate. And in a battle for democracy, clear-headed citizens are the greatest defense.

What makes it hard for you to calm down and carry on right now? What strategies would you recommend to others?